Pet Friendly 2 Bedroom Bayfront House Anna Maria Island, FL

Bay Haven is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath duplex on the waterfront of Bimini Bay in Anna Maria, Florida. This single-level home sleeps 4 and is set up with two king bedrooms, making it well suited to guests who want a smaller, easy-to-navigate layout with bay views. A screened-in lanai facing the water and an outdoor grill add simple ways to spend time outside, and the home is dog friendly with host approval.

Inside, the living area is arranged in an open-concept plan with a TV and seating for downtime between outings. The full kitchen includes major appliances and everyday essentials such as a refrigerator, stove, oven, microwave, dishwasher, toaster, and coffee maker. Practical conveniences include air conditioning, ceiling fans, internet access, towels/linens, and an in-home washer/dryer. The primary bedroom has an ensuite bathroom with a walk-in shower, while the second king bedroom is next to a full bath with a tub/shower combination. Parking is available for up to four cars, and contactless check-in is offered.

Good fit for

Pet-friendly stays Long-term stays

Waterfront on Bimini Bay Duplex set on the bay with a screened-in waterfront lanai.

Two king bedrooms Sleeping setup includes 2 king beds and 2 full bathrooms.

Dog friendly Dogs are allowed with host approval before check-in (no cats).

Full kitchen and laundry Includes full kitchen plus an in-home washer/dryer.

Parking for four cars On-site parking is available for up to 4 vehicles.

Waterfront - BayLocation Setting

Near a BeachBeach Access

2 BedroomsBedrooms

2 Full BathroomsBathrooms

Sleeps 4Guest Capacity

1155 sq. ft.Living Space

Internet AccessInternet

TelevisionTelevision

YesAir Conditioning

YesPet Friendly

YesWasher / Dryer

Sleeping Arrangements 2 King Beds

Virtual Tour Bay Haven - Virtual Tour

Anna Maria Florida

510 South Dr Unit A, Anna Maria Florida 34216

Location & nearby Explore the Area

Bay Haven is on a residential street in Anna Maria on Anna Maria Island, set directly on the waterfront of Bimini Bay. The listing notes it is near a beach and describes access by walking or biking to Pine Avenue, Bayfront Park, and the historic City Pier. The setting is positioned for bay activities, with kayaks and paddleboards allowed (the dock itself is not for guest use).

Anna Maria Vacation Rentals Sandbar Seafood & Spirits in Anna Maria Florida Bean Point Beach Bayfront Park Beach

Rates from

$159 per night

2-day minimum stay

Check current rates & availability

Live booking details are maintained by AMI Locals.

Check Availability

Other Availability Information

Bayfront 2 bedroom home that allows pets on Anna Maria Island, FL

Bay Haven is a waterfront duplex on Bimini Bay in Anna Maria, Florida, offering a single-level setup with 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms for up to four guests. The home’s layout centers on an open living and kitchen area oriented toward the bay, with a TV for relaxed evenings and a straightforward flow between indoor and outdoor spaces.

The kitchen is equipped for preparing meals during your stay, with a full-size refrigerator and freezer, stove, oven, microwave, dishwasher, toaster, and coffee maker, along with dishes, utensils, pots, pans, and wine glasses. A dining table provides a dedicated place to eat, and the home includes everyday comforts such as air conditioning, heating, ceiling fans, hot water, towels/linens, and internet access. Laundry is handled in-house with a washer/dryer, and practical items like an iron/ironing board and hair dryer are provided.

Sleeping arrangements include two king beds. The primary bedroom includes an ensuite bathroom with a walk-in shower. The second bedroom also has a king bed and is positioned near the second full bathroom, which has a tub/shower combination.

Outdoor features include a screened-in waterfront lanai with seating, outdoor lighting, and a grill. Although there is a boat dock on site, it is not for guest use; kayaks and paddleboards are allowed. The property is on a residential street and offers a private entrance, safety features such as smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, and parking for up to four vehicles (no additional overnight parking). Long-term stays are allowed, and dogs are accepted with host approval prior to check-in (no cats).

Bay Haven by AMI Locals
Vacation Rental License #VR16-000039

Welcome to Bay Haven, a relaxing 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom duplex waterfront retreat nestled along peaceful Bimini Bay. Just a short walk or bike ride to Pine Avenue’s shops, Bayfront Park, and the historic City Pier, this charming single-level home is perfect for couples or small families looking to experience the laid-back lifestyle of Anna Maria Island.

Highlights
• Duplex
• Waterfront views on Bimini Bay
• 2 Bedrooms / 2 Bathrooms
• 2 King beds
• Dog friendly
• Less than 1 mile to Pine Avenue, City Pier, and Bayfront Park
• 1 mile to Palmetto Avenue Beach
• Screened waterfront deck
• BBQ grill
• 4 Car parking

Wake up to gentle bay breezes and spend your mornings sipping coffee on the screened waterfront deck as boats drift by on Bimini Bay. The tranquil outdoor space features cozy rocking chairs and a BBQ grill, perfect for sunset dinners or island-style lunches.

Step inside and you’re welcomed by a bright and casual open concept living area with panoramic bay views. The living room offers comfy seating and a large TV for post-beach movie nights. The well-equipped kitchen includes full-size appliances, ample cabinet space, and everything you need to prepare snacks or family meals.

The primary suite is a restful haven with a king bed, waterfront views, and a private ensuite bathroom with a walk-in shower. The second bedroom also features a king bed and is conveniently located next to the second full bathroom, which includes a tub/shower combo.

Room Details
-Primary Bedroom: King bed with ensuite bathroom (walk-in shower)
-Second Bedroom: King bed with adjacent bathroom (shower/tub combo)

Take kayaking adventures on Bimini Bay to explore the boutique shops on Pine Avenue or lounge at the nearby Palmetto Avenue Beach, Bay Haven offers the perfect balance of relaxation and activity.

From peaceful mornings on the bay to beach days and downtown strolls, Bay Haven offers a perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and coastal charm. Whether you're looking for a romantic couples' getaway or a small family retreat, this pet-friendly Anna Maria Island rental provides a quiet yet central location for making lasting memories!

-
Dock is not for guest use, kayaks and paddleboards allowed

*Please note: 4 cars maximum are able to park at this home. We ask our guests to please plan accordingly and coordinate with your group. There is no overnight parking available for additional vehicles.

This home is managed by AMI Locals, an Anna Maria Island property management company.

We do not accept reservations from anyone under 25 years of age. We do not allow persons under 25 to occupy a property unless accompanied by someone over 25 years of age.

With host approval before check-in, this property accepts dogs only (No cats or other animals are allowed). An additional pet fee will apply. See our AMI Locals Rental Policies for full details.

Please Remember: "You are vacationing in a residential area. Please be a good neighbor by keeping the noise to a respectful level during the day and night. Excessive and unreasonable noise can deprive neighbors of the peaceful enjoyment of their private property." *Exceeding the noise ordinance could result in disciplinary actions including fines and/or termination of your rental agreement without refund.

Check In

4:00 PM

Check Out

10:00 AM

This property provides access to the following activities and special interests:

Beach

Biking

Boating

Canoeing

Deep Sea Fishing

Family Vacations

Fishing

Fly Fishing

Golfing

Kayaking

Ocean

Pet Friendly

Sailing

Scuba Diving

State National Parks

Surfing

Wind Surfing

Honeymoon

Other Activities and Special Interests

Museums Nearby

Boating Nearby

Local Eco Tourism Nearby

Horseback Riding Nearby

Outlet Shopping Nearby

Wildlife Viewing Nearby

Fitness Center Nearby

Laundromat Close By

Tennis Court Nearby

Basketball Court Nearby

Hiking Nearby

Jet Skiing Nearby

Parasailing Nearby

Sailing Nearby

Snorkeling Nearby

Surfing Nearby

Swimming Nearby

Health Beauty Spa Nearby

Marina Nearby

Shopping Nearby

Bird Watching Nearby

Kayaking Nearby

Water Sports Nearby

Featured Amenities

Air Conditioning

Dishwasher

Grill

Internet Access

Pets Allowed

Television

Washer/Dryer

Property Features

Ceiling Fan(s)

Coffee Maker

Freezer

Full Kitchen

Hair Dryer

Microwave

Oven

Refrigerator

Stove

Toaster

Towels/Linens

Outdoor

Boat Dock

Other Property Amenities

Residential Street

Anna Maria

Anna Maria Island

Dishes and Utensils

Fire Extinguisher

Living Room

Clothes Hangers

Heating

Hot Water

Long Term Stays Allowed

Private Entrance

Smoke Detector

Hospital Close By

Carbon Monoxide Detector

Deadbolt Lock

Pots and Pans

Contactless Check-In

Pack 'n Play

Iron and Ironing Board

Patio

Ground Floor Property

Dining Table

Two (2) Parking Spaces

Outdoor Seating

Water Front

Clothing Storage

Wine Glasses

Baking Sheet

Screened-In Lanai

Outdoor Lighting

Shared Spaces

5

Everything was great! The host was highly responsive and helpful.

Abby

Posted: 8/31/2026

It’s great to know everything came together so smoothly at Bay Haven by AMI Locals, Abby! We especially appreciate your kind words about our team and are glad the communication and support helped make your stay easy and enjoyable. Having a responsive host can make all the difference when you’re simply trying to relax and enjoy your time on the island. We’d love to welcome you back to Bay Haven for another carefree Anna Maria Island getaway!

AMI Locals staff

5

PAM

Posted: 8/13/2026

5

Check in was seamless. We used this property for extra family members for a reunion weekend and it was nice for four people. We would consider this property again for future weekends.

Ann Marie R.

Posted: 7/27/2026

We're so glad Bay Haven by AMI Locals worked out so well for your family reunion weekend, Selena. It's wonderful to hear the check-in process was seamless and that the home provided a comfortable space for your family members during such a special gathering. Thank you for choosing to stay with us. We're honored you'd consider Bay Haven again, and we look forward to welcoming you back for another memorable stay on AMI.

AMI Locals staff

4

The house was good, the back porch was great, there was just very limited blankets and household items. It felt more like a hotel than it did a home. We loved sitting on the back porch and watching the water.the sheets were hard.

Narissa

Posted: 7/16/2026

Thank you for sharing your experience at Bay Haven by AMI Locals, Narissa. We're so glad you enjoyed relaxing on the back porch and taking in the beautiful waterfront views, it's one of our favorite features of the home. We also appreciate your feedback regarding the blankets, household items, and bedding. We strive to provide the essentials for a comfortable stay, and your suggestions will be shared with the homeowner as they consider future enhancements to the home. Thank you again for your thoughtful comments, and we hope to welcome you back for another relaxing island getaway soon!

AMI Locals staff

4

Cute Rental very comfortable couch! Mattresses not so much super firm woke up sore. Also didn’t realize we’d be sharing a backyard Space with other occupants in the duplex. Didn’t even realize it was a duplex lol other than that, it was a great stay!

Stephanie

Posted: 7/8/2026

We're so glad you enjoyed your stay at Bay Haven by AMI Locals and found the home to be a comfortable place to relax, Stephanie! We appreciate you sharing your feedback about the mattresses, as comfort preferences can certainly vary from guest to guest. To clarify, the listing photos do show that the home is part of a duplex and illustrate the shared backyard layout. That said, we appreciate your comments and will review the listing to see if there's anything we can do to make this even clearer for future guests. Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback, and we hope to welcome you back for another island getaway soon!

AMI Locals staff

5

Home was in great location, close to Bean Point, close to shopping but far enough from crowds. Loved being able to sit on pier and read or just enjoy the view. Fishing was great off pier as well and was fun to just walk out and toss rod in any time. Home was clean and as pictured, good space for our family. We rented golf cart which was lifesaver when came to parking while out on island. It was nice having the wagon/umbrella/chairs available. Only downside was finding nails in driveway, I didn’t report but did pick them up as I found them and tossed in trash. With last years storms and pier replacement I just didn’t feel need to complain, no flats so no worries. Would be fun to rent both units for whole family and would definitely rent again.

Alysia K.

Posted: 6/7/2026

Being able to walk out to the pier with a book in hand or a fishing rod is one of the things that makes this spot so special, Bradley. We're glad Bay Haven by AMI Locals was a great fit for your family and that you enjoyed the peaceful location near Bean Point while still being close to shopping and everything the island has to offer. Having the beach gear ready to go and a golf cart for getting around certainly makes island life even easier. Thank you as well for letting us know about the nails in the driveway. We appreciate you bringing that to our attention and will share it with our team so they can take a closer look and help ensure the area remains clear for future guests. We're delighted you enjoyed your stay and love the idea of renting both units for a larger family gathering someday. We'd be happy to welcome you back to Bay Haven for more fishing, bay views, and relaxing island days!

AMI Locals staff

5

The rental was cozy, clean, and very comfortable. It was wonderful to wake up each morning and enjoy a cup of coffee on our dock overlooking the bay. The peaceful setting made our stay especially relaxing. The host checked in via phone during our stay to make sure everything was going well and to see if we needed anything. We would definitely return!

Susan

Posted: 6/7/2026

Nothing beats sipping your morning coffee by the bay and watching the water wake up with you, Susan. The dock at Bay Haven by AMI Locals has a way of slowing things down and helping you settle into that easy island pace. We're so glad you enjoyed the peaceful setting, comfortable accommodations, and those quiet moments overlooking the water. It also means a lot to hear that the team helped make your stay even better by checking in along the way. Those little touches can make a vacation feel a little more like home. Thank you for spending your island time with us. We'd love to welcome you back for more sunrise coffees, bay views, and relaxing days on AMI!

AMI Locals staff

5

Beautiful back view!!! This spot was perfect for my small family.

Manuel

Posted: 5/27/2026

That beautiful backyard view has a way of making it hard to leave, Manuel. We're so happy Bay Haven by AMI Locals was the perfect fit for your family. Whether it was enjoying a quiet morning coffee or winding down after a day at the beach, those peaceful water views make every moment feel a little more special. Thanks for spending your island time with us, and we hope to welcome your family back for another relaxing getaway soon!

AMI Locals staff

5

Great location. Easy check in. All you needed was provided.

Shelley

Posted: 4/12/2026

That’s an easy island win, Shelley! We’re so glad Bay Haven by AMI Locals made your stay smooth from the start. Great location, simple check-in, and everything you need right there that’s how it should be. Hope to have you back for another effortless getaway soon!

AMI Locals staff

5

Great location! Close to several beaches and a few blocks to restaurants and shops. Home was clean and had everything we needed for the week. Would rent again!

Kari

Posted: 4/5/2026

That’s a solid island setup right there, Kari! We’re so glad Bay Haven by AMI Locals had everything you needed for the week. Being close to the beaches and just a few blocks from shops and restaurants really makes it easy to settle into vacation mode. Love that you’d come back that’s the best compliment. We’ll be ready for your next stay!

AMI Locals staff