New Buffalo Michigan Vacation Rentals and Vacation Homes


Bluefish Vacation Rentals
Click for Phone Number
Top vacation homes in all of “Harbor Country”, featuring Union Pier, from one-bedroom cottages and bungalows, to exceptional 2- to 5-bedroom properties. Some of our listings have lake views, or are in close p...

Beach Combers Vacation...
Click for Phone Number
Beach Combers Vacation Rentals is nestled on the harbor wall in the heart of Harbor Country. Representing some of the areas most premium vacation rentals. We offer homes in Ogden Dunes, Sheridan Beach, Long B...

Be Our Guest
Click for Phone Number
Be Our Guest for the best in style and comfort Southwest Michigan has to offer. We deliver solid assurance that you will enjoy your stay by providing housing and customized concierge services that will make t...

 27 Rentals in New Buffalo

Displaying 1-25 of 27

 »

Show Properties  

»

Sort Properties by Clear all Filters
  • Bedrooms
  • Sleeps
  • Bathrooms
  • Amenities

    Furnishings & Luxuries

         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         

    Kitchen & Appliances

             
             
             
     

    Electronics

           
           
           
           
       

    Activities & Recreation

         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         

    Transportation

         
       
Property 106080

Grand Beach Inn

  • This is the ideal location for all sorts of gatherings, with enough room for big families or any type of large group!
  • House in New Buffalo
  • 14 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 45
Property 105905

Warren Woods Inn

  • Huge Home For Family Reunions and Group Vacations-Sleeps 30 People
  • Inn in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 12 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 30
  • 5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $6,000 - $12,500
Property 105911

White House and Cottage

  • Sleeps 14 and Just 100 Yards to Great Beach Access
  • House in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 6 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 14
  • 3 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,200 - $4,600
Property 105912

Grand Cottage

  • Large 6 Bedroom/4 Bathroom House That Sleeps 14 - Pool access
  • House in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 6 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 14
  • 4 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,000 - $4,200
Property 14396

Blue Fish Guest House

  • Blue Fish Guest House in Union Pier Michigan. Union Pier 5 bedroom Vacation Homes
  • Cottage in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 5 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 10-12
  • 3 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,100 - $2,900
Property 14492

Beach Pass

  • Beach Pass - Beautiful Brand New Lake Michigan 5 Bedroom Vacation Home
  • House in New Buffalo (Near Michiana)
  • 5 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8-10
  • 4.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $3,540 - $4,550
Property 46451

Idle Days

  • Beautiful 5 bedroom home less than a block to the beach!
  • Cottage in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 5 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 10
  • 4.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $3,100 - $4,250
Property 94711

Michigan Memories

  • Nice big yard, plus deck and hot tub
  • Cottage in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 5 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 10
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,225 - $2,700
Property 14494

Blue Heaven mi

  • Blue Heaven - Great In-Town Location with In Ground Pool - Walk to Beach
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Union Pier)
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 10-12
  • 3 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,895 - $3,595
  • Harbor House in New Buffalo near the marina. Lake Michigan Luxury Vacation Homes
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Lake Michigan)
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8-10
  • 4.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $3,600 - $4,100
Property 46456

Match Point Cottage

  • Fireplace, Sauna, and Private Tennis Court!
  • Cottage in Lakeside (Near New Buffalo)
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 10
  • 3 Bathroom(s)
Property 94710

Dunewood Beach House

  • On the beach, with access to the association pool!
  • Condo in New Buffalo
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 9
  • 4.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $3,250 - $4,250
Property 94712

Stollaway

  • New Listing
  • Cottage in Harbert (Near New Buffalo)
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 12
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,000 - $2,450
Property 94714

La Dolce Vita

  • Architectural beauty with heated pool!
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Union Pier)
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 12
  • 3.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $3,900 - $4,400
Property 105910

Lakeside House with Pool

  • Fun Private House is Lakeside with Pool, Hot Tub and Fire Pit
  • House in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 4 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 14
  • 2.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $2,000 - $4,200
Property 14495

Blue J. Way

  • Blue J. Way - Lakeside Michigan Cottage - Across the street from the Beach
  • Cottage in Lakeside (Near New Buffalo)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8-9
  • 3 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $1,950 - $2,600
Property 14515

Little Stone Beach House

  • Little Stone Beach House. New Buffalo Vacation Rental
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Lake Michigan)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8-9
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • The Lake House: Luxury Three Bedroom on the Lake
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Union Pier)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8
  • 3.5 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $4,100 - $5,250
Property 24414

Willow Cottage

  • Willow Cottage : Year-round, Close to the Beach Vacation Rental in New Buffalo's "Riviera"
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Association Beach)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
Property 30003

All Decked Out in Sawyer

  • All Decked Out: Delightful cottage near Warren Dunes State Park
  • Cottage in Sawyer (Near New Buffalo)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $1,400 - $1,700
Property 46450

The Pines

  • Newly refinished with a fully stocked “cooks kitchen”
  • Cottage in Harbert (Near New Buffalo)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 6
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $1,525 - $2,125
Property 46455

North Star Cottage

  • Located in Union Pier, less than ½ a block to the beach access.
  • Cottage in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 6
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
Property 91949

Carefree Cottage

  • Located in Paradise Villa Association, Union Pier, less than ½ a block to the beach access.
  • Cottage in Union Pier (Near New Buffalo)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 8
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $1,700 - $2,100
Property 91950

Merchant Street Retreat

  • Great Location within walking distance to all of New Buffalo
  • Cottage in New Buffalo (Near Union Pier)
  • 3 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 9
  • 2 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $1,350 - $1,850
Property 14469

Condo at Southcove

  • Condo at Southcove - New Buffalo, Michigan condo rental
  • Condo in New Buffalo (Near Lake Michigan)
  • 2 Bedroom(s), Sleeps 6
  • 1 Bathroom(s)
  • Weekly Rates from $1,400 - $1,700


Need Help Finding an Accommodation?

Fill out the form below and/or contact us at 866-218-5743.

Your Name
Email Address
Phone Number
Location of Interest
Adults Children
Checking In Checking Out