FR Beach Rentals
Vacation Rental Managers Testimonials Manager Login
Book Direct & Save with a Vacation Rental Manager
Vacation Rental Managers Testimonials
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals - Eleuthera Island in the Bahamas!
Book Direct
Number of Guests
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
more filters
Price Range
Amenities
  Air Conditioning
  Dishwasher
  Fireplace
  Grill
  Hot Tub (Private)
  Luxury
  Pets Allowed
  Pool (Private)
  Ski-in/Ski-out
  Washer/Dryer
  Wheelchair Accessible
Activities and Interests
  Beach
  Biking
  Boating
  Canoeing
  Casino
  Corporate and Executive
  Fishing
  Deep Sea Fishing
  For Sale
  Golfing
  Group and Reunion
  Honeymoon
  Horseback Riding
  Hunting
  Lake
  Mountain Biking
  State National Parks
  Nightclub and Disco
  Over 55 Community
  Sailing
  Scuba Diving
  Skiing
  Cross Country Skiing
  Snowmobiling
  Spa
  Surfing
  Theatre
  Wedding
  White Water Rafting
  Wineries and Vineyards
  Fly Fishing
  Wind Surfing
  Hang Gliding
  Disney
  LegoLand
  Hiking
  Rental Exchange
  Specials
  Ultra Luxury
  Family Vacations
  Kayaking
BOOK DIRECT

Save on Fees and Experience Professional Service

IDEA DRIVEN VACATIONS

Search for Travel Guides, News, Events, Special Interests, and More!

  • Activities and Interests

    Uncover fun activities and special interests for your upcoming trip

  • Event Travel

    Plan your trip around concerts, festivals, and special events worth traveling for

  • Attractions

    Explore top landmarks, scenic spots, and can't-miss local highlights

  • Travel Guides

    Navigate each location like a local with our detailed travel guides

  • Travel News

    Stay updated with the latest travel trends and vacation rental tips

  • Trip Ideas

    Find inspiration for your next getaway with curated trip suggestions and themes

  • Travel Newsletter

    Join our newsletter for exclusive travel insights, featured destinations, and trip planning tips

Vacation Rentals by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals - Eleuthera Island in the Bahamas!

  1. « Fort Myers Rentals

All Vacation Rentals from Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Sorted by
Main Lodge veranda with 50 mile ocean and sunset view.
$3,066/night
Buttonwood Reserve Compound...
Condo in Governors Harbour Bahamas
17 Beds • 17 Full Baths • Sleeps 46
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Cocodimama, a boutique beachfront resort available for private rental.
$2,805/night
Cocodimama Resort - Boutiqu...
Hotel in Governors Harbour Bahamas
14 Beds • 16 Full Baths • Sleeps 35
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Pink Sands Point, private beachfront estate on the the Banks Road of Governors Harbour, walking distance to Tippy's famous beachfront restaurant and bar.
$1,800/night
Pink Sands Point · Brand Ne...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
10 Beds • 1 Full Bath • Sleeps 26
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Cocodimama, a boutique beachfront resort available for private rental.
$2,155/night
Cocodimama small · Boutique...
Hotel in Governors Harbour Bahamas
10 Beds • 11 Full Baths • Sleeps 20
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
View from the west deck, facing the sunset Deck has covered and open areas.
$1,225/night
Buttonwood Reserve Bldg 2 -...
Condo in Governors Harbour Bahamas
8 Beds • 8 Full Baths • Sleeps 24
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Located on the prestigious Banks Rd., the prime location on Eleuthera, Snaresbrook Manor sits
$3,600/night
Snaresbrook Manor - Ultra-L...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
8 Beds • 9 Full Baths • Sleeps 22
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Sky Cove, a luxurious new estate home on a private cove in central Eleuthera.
$990/night
Sky Cove - Spectacular Beac...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
7 Beds • 6 Full Baths • Sleeps 17
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Middle Cay - A private island 5 minutes from Harbour Island, rented to just one group at a time.
$2,969/night
Middle Cay - Luxurious Priv...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
7 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 17
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to the Bohemia Estate, a private 3-acre estate located directly on a mile-long pink-sand beach near Governors Harbour.
$2,060/night
Bohemia Estate · Bohemia -...
Estate in Gregory Town Bahamas
6 Beds • 7 Full Baths • Sleeps 18
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Kataluma, a beachfront estate on Double Bay.
$1,237/night
Kataluma - Private Estate o...
Home in Double Bay Bahamas
6 Beds • 6 Full Baths • Sleeps 16
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Alfred House is located on a point between two spectacular beaches.
$1,450/night
Alfred & Cottage · Stylish...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
6 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 14
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Beachfront infinity pool with 50 mile view.
$1,105/night
Sandy Hill · New Beachfront...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
6 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 14
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Buccaneer Hill luxuriously restored historic home with pool overlooking the harbor. Walk to town and beach.
$1,375/night
Buccaneer Hill · Luxuriousl...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
6 Beds • 6 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Trident private beachfront estate with guest cottage.
$1,125/night
Trident Estate - Newly Remo...
Estate in North Palmetto Point Bahamas
6 Beds • 6 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Allamanda House. Our rooftop living area overlooking the pool.
$1,575/night
Allamanda Harbour Island -...
Home in Dunmore Town Bahamas
6 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to SeaEsta House! Enjoy our Pool with a VIEW. This property is located on the calm Caribbean shore of Eleuthera.
$710/night
SeaEsta - Brand New Estate...
Home in Palmetto Point Bahamas
6 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Folly with breathtaking views of the Harbour from sunrise to sunset.
$650/night
Folly & Guest House - Histo...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
6 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Windchat, beachfront estate with heated ocean-view infinity pool, tennis court, pickleball, basketball, shuffleboard, kayaks, foosball, ping-pong and more.
$1,500/night
Windchat - Priv. Beachfront...
Estate in North Palmetto Point Bahamas
6 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 11
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Touch of Class Estate. Our decks have the best ocean views on the island! Steps lead right down into the water with a perfect sandy bottom.
$790/night
Touch of Class Estate - A B...
Home in Savannah Sound Bahamas
5 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 14
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Tir Na Nog, an elegantly appointed 10-acre beachfront estate with heated pool on the Banks Road, Eleuthera's premier location.
$989/night
Tir Na Nog · 10-Acre Beachf...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Our new heated oceanfront pool.
$850/night
Endless Summer - Private 5-...
Home in Double Bay Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Neptune Cove. Swim in our clifftop infinity edge pool with swim up bar.
$755/night
Neptune Cove - Cliff-Top Es...
Estate in Rainbow Bay Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Private beachfront estate, On the Rocks, located on a mile-long pink-sand beach.
$875/night
On the Rocks · Secluded Pin...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to The Better Life, a brand new house just completed in April of 2024. The house is visible in this photo just to the right of the beach path.
$790/night
Better Life & Cottage · New...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Buccaneer Hill sits high on a hilltop overlooking Governors Harbour and the Caribbean Sea beyond.
$1,075/night
Buccaneer Hill 5BR · Luxuri...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Cricket Beach, a brand new (February 2025) luxury estate directly on Eleuthera's world-class pink sand beach
$1,150/night
Cricket Beach House-Luxurio...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Alfred House! Alfred House is located on a point between two spectacular beaches,
$1,150/night
Alfred · Stylish & Private...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Exterior of Main House "Conch Shell House" - view of pool and yard.
$1,570/night
Conch Shell Harbour Island...
Home in Dunmore Town Bahamas
5 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Beautiful new home is perched on a cliff overlooking the Caribbean
$465/night
Blue Love Point · New Luxur...
Home in Gregory Town Bahamas
5 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Living room with sliding glass wall to sun deck
$735/night
Provender · Historic Home D...
Home in Windermere Island Bahamas
5 Beds • 5 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Aerial view of Beehive.
$3,500/night
Beehive Harbour Island. Lux...
Home in Dunmore Town Bahamas
5 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Bahama Mama! Our new heated private pool.
$695/night
Bahama Mama · Mint Home w/P...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 8
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
The Little White House, meticulously renovated 5-bedroom, 3-bath vacation rental home.
$375/night
The Little White House -Ren...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
5 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 8
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Sea Walk and pool from above
$535/night
Sea Walk · Beach Villa w/Po...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Palisade's new heated oceanfront infinity pool overlooking our mile-long pink sand beach.
$842/night
Palisades - Stunning Beachf...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Aeiral view of Moonflower House on Gaulding Cay Beach.
$395/night
Moonflower on Beautiful Gau...
Home in Gregory Town Bahamas
4 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 12
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Aerial view of house
$525/night
Indigo House · Newly Update...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Caribbean Sandcastle, a stunning beachfront house with pool and hot tub direclty on a mile-long Caribbean beach.
$810/night
Caribbean SandCastle - Priv...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Villa Exterior at Night
$560/night
Sky Beach Club Waterfall Vi...
Villa in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Villa Exterior at Night
$560/night
Sky Beach Club Vine House ·...
Villa in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to The Better Life, a brand new house just completed in April of 2024. The house is visible in this photo just to the right of the beach path.
$550/night
Better Life · New Banks Roa...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 10
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Miss Ruby
$490/night
Miss Ruby - 4-Acre Estate o...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Aerial view of Salty Dolphin House, formerly Richview House.
$555/night
Salty Dolphin - Beach House...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Sand Dollar at Ten Bay Beach, a true gift of the Caribbean
$575/night
Sand Dollar Ten Bay - 4BR H...
Home in Ten Bay Beach Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Welcome to Ananda Estate. View from the Main House toward the pool and beach.
$1,911/night
Ananda - Luxury Beachfront...
Estate in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Plage Rose and its guest cottage. 700 feet on the beach!
$853/night
Plage Rose Estate · Seclude...
Home in Double Bay Bahamas
4 Beds • 3 Full Baths • Sleeps 9
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Private beach in front of Windsong. Just another day in paradise!
$660/night
Windsong · Grand Beachfront...
Home in Double Bay Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 8
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
Beautiful beach house with in-ground private pool and extensive yard and gardens
$435/night
Driftwood · Renovated Priva...
Home in Governors Harbour Bahamas
4 Beds • 4 Full Baths • Sleeps 8
Eleuthera Vacation Rentals